Greater
Southwest International Airport, located
between Dallas and Fort Worth, Texas,
was to be the site of two training
flights on the morning of May 30, 1972.
Just after 5:00am, an American Airlines
DC-10 took off from Love Field, arriving
at Greater Southwest shortly afterwards,
where it began a series of
touch-and-goes. An hour and a half
later, Delta N3305L, a DC-9, departed
Love Field for Greater Southwest,
requesting practice approaches. On board
the aircraft was a Delta check pilot,
two First Officers undergoing command
training, and an FAA inspector.
The American aircraft had been using
runway 13 and N3305L was cleared for an
ILS approach behind it. After landing,
the aircraft taxied back to the
threshold of runway 13, requesting
another ILS approach. After making it's
approach, again behind the American
aircraft, N3305L executed a missed
approach and asked for a VOR approach to
runway 35. After beginning the approach,
the crew asked for a missed approach to
be followed by a circle-to-land approach
at low level to runway 17. As the crew
entered a downwind for 17, it realized a
possible conflict with the American
aircraft landing on runway 13, so they
asked to land on runway 13 behind the
DC-10 instead of 17.
The Tower replied "OK. That'll be
fine...use runway 13 for a full stop.
Caution...wake turbulence." The last
part was required practice whenever an
aircraft approaches behind a heavy jet
with less than 2,500ft separating the
two. However, the aircraft never got
closer than two miles. N3305L was just
turning on final when the DC-10 touched
down. Delta's aircraft was configured
for landing and stabilized on approach
until just a few seconds before landing
when it's port wing dropped. This was
apparently over-corrected by the crew as
the right wing then dropped followed by
another roll to the left.
Then, just as the aircraft crossed
the threshold, at an altitude of about
50ft, the right wing dropped sharply and
impacted the runway as the aircraft
rolled through vertical. The aircraft
fell to the runway on it's back,
exploding as it slid some 2,000ft until
coming to rest. All four of the
occupants were killed.
......It seemed clear that the only
explanation for the accident was wake
turbulence, though it was previously
thought that it only affected small
aircraft. Analysis of both aircraft's
flight path's showed that N3305L would
have passed through the DC-10's flight
path, approaching it's wake vortices at
approximately 60 feet just less than a
minute after the DC-10 touched down.
Meteorological conditions at the time
would have been conducive to the wake
vortices staying in the threshold zone
for more than two minutes. Recovery of
the aircraft's recorders showed that it
encountered a gust registering 1.7gs
during which the check captain was heard
to say "A little turbulence here!" As
the encounter continued, the captain
then said "Let's go round" followed by
"Takeoff power!"
The aircraft then encountered a gust
of -1g as the aircraft rolled onto it's
back. Study of the physics of the wake
vortices showed that even full aileron
deflection could not have overcome the
tremendous roll rate created by the
DC-10's wake. This accident prompted the
FAA to instate new separation standards
for wake turbulence avoidance.
|