It was a nasty
afternoon in Miami the day of February 12, 1963. A Northwest
Airlines Boeing 720, designated flight 705, was scheduled to depart
at 1:30pm bound for Portland, Oregon. On the flight deck that day
was Captain Roy Almquist and First Officer Robert Feller. Along
with the flight engineer and five cabin attendants, only
thirty-five passengers boarded for the first leg to Chicago. A
squall line was lying to the northwest of the city, slowly moving
southeast. Associated with this line were thunderstorm cells up to
20 miles in diameter, some reaching as high as 40,000ft. A sigmet
had been issued for moderate to severe turbulence with a chance of
extreme turbulence inside the storms. The crew asked for a
southeast departure, hoping to go around or over the top of the
worst of the weather. After heading south east initially, the
aircraft was vectored back north at 5000ft. Feller called Miami,
asking for a higher altitude and reporting that "We're in the clear
now. We can see it out ahead...it looks pretty bad." 705 was then
cleared to climb to FL250 and said they would be turning 30 degrees
left, giving them and approximate heading of 270 degrees. Feller
then told Miami that turbulence was "moderate to heavy" and then
advised them "OK, you better run the rest of them off the other
way." After being handed off to Miami Centre, Feller reported that
they were climbing through 17,500ft. This transmission, thirteen
minutes after takeoff, was the last from 705. Shortly after,
several people located in the Everglades heard a loud explosion
followed by a ground tremor. One women reported seeing what looked
like "a ball of flame in the edge of a cloud."
......Wreckage was strewn over some
fifteen miles, indicating an in-flight break-up of the aircraft.
While it was clear the weather was severe in the area, sabotage
could not be ruled out nor could some other sort of component
failure, the aircraft having been involved in a landing accident a
few months prior.
Reconstructed
Wreckage of 705
Collection of the
wreckage showed that the tail surfaces had broken off downward
while the forward fuselage separated upwards. All four engines had
separated upward as well. Readout of the FDR showed that showed
that the aircraft had encountered some heavy turbulence while
climbing to 15,000ft until it turned more westerly. It then turned
back northwest and began to climb again, at one point obtaining a
climb rate of 9000ft/min until reaching just over 19,000ft. At this
point, the vertical acceleration suddenly became negative 2gs,
increasing even further with fluctuations up to negative 2.8gs, the
airspeed continuing to increase as well. Vertical acceleration
abruptly went back to positive 1.5gs. During it's descent, the
airspeed increased until the FDR was no longer able to accurately
measure it, greater than 470kts. Analysis showed that the aircraft
would have reached some 22 degrees pitch up during it's dramatic
climb to beyond vertical in it's final descent. Structural tests of
the 720 showed that it could have withstood the initial excessive
forces brought on by the thunderstorm gusts. It appeared that the
aircraft did not break up until the crew apparently tried to
recover when passing through 10,000ft. The question then was what
caused the aircraft to get into such an unusual condition. The
answer came in the fact that the aircraft has an inherit tendency
to 'weathervane' into gusts. So, when the initial updraft caught
the aircraft, it would have an initial tendency to nose down into
the gust. This apparently prompted Almquist to give nose-up inputs,
which would actually worsen the overall situation. The same effect
worked in the downdraft which followed. It is also important to
note that, although it appears full up elevator was used in the
recovery attempt, full nose-down trim was still wound in from the
prior encounter with the updraft. Boeing tests showed that recovery
from the dive in this condition beyond 320kts is not possible.
|