There were weak spots in the Piper
Cub that were known but really show up when raising the gross
weight. The SC is a J3 with a higher gross and a bigger engine. The
distance between joints on the longerons behind the cockpit was too
long on the J3, so for the SC small tubes were welded in from the
top joints to the mid span of the lower longeron. This stopped the
longeron from bowing up or down. Then tubes were welded across the
bottom from this new joint to the new joint on the other side. Now
the longeron can't bow sideways, but it can still bow towards the
centre of the fuse.
If you hired a
structural engineer to design a new fuselage and he brought you
these drawings, you would think he was a lunatic. Obviously the
Piper engineers were not lunatics, what happened? Two forces govern
production airplanes: the certification and the bottom line. It
would have been an expensive violation of the type certificate to
redesign the structure, cheaper to put "bandaids" on it. We didn't
have these restrictions so we added an extra set of diagonals to the
fuselage, shortening the spans in a structurally sound way.
This
also solves the known weak link at the tail spring mount area. Two
other weak spots were related to crash protection rather than flight
loads. The diagonal in the cockpit ceiling handles extreme loads in
tension only. If in compression it can pop violently down and
penetrate the pilot's head. Adding a cross brace up there solves
this problem. The other area is the side bay of the fuselage
immediately aft of the fire wall. A very hard landing can cause the
weight of the engine to swing down compressing the bottom longeron,
making "s" curves in the floor. In a crash the firewall can be
pushed back breaking the pilot's ankles! Again a cross-brace instead
of a diagonal makes this less likely.
specifications
powerplant
propeller
length
height
wing span
wing area
seats
empty weight
useful load
gross weight
fuel capacity
range |
Lycoming 0320
(150 hp).
82-41
prop
x
x
36' 4".
x
x
1170-1250 lbs.
x
2000-2200 lbs. (2300 on floats)
52 U.S.
gal./44 Imp. gal./197 L.
x |
performance
takeoff distance,
ground roll
rate of climb
max speed
cruise speed
landing distance, ground roll
service ceiling |
180 ft
1000 fpm
x
98 mph.
85 mph.
on 2000
floats
x
x |
limiting and recommended speeds
design manoeuvring speed (Va)
never exceed speed (Vne)
stall, power off (Vsl)
landing approach speed |
x
x
40 mph
x |
All specifications are based on manufacturer's
calculations
|